In this blog post, we will look at what groupthink is, the different types of groupthink, the causes of groupthink, and how to avoid it. We will also look at the positives and negatives of groupthink.
Contents
Understanding Groupthink
Groupthink is a type of thinking that can happen when people are in a group. It is a kind of thinking where people agree with each other without really thinking about the issue. This can be dangerous because it can lead to bad decisions being made.
Groupthink Vs. Conformity
Conformity is when people do what others do because they want to fit in. Groupthink is different from conformity because it is when people agree with each other without really thinking about the issue. This can be dangerous because it can lead to bad decisions being made.
Types of Groupthink
There are different types of groupthink. However, the most common types are:
The rationalization of decisions: This is when people make bad decisions and then try to find a reason why they made the decision.
- Example: The company decided to lay off some workers. The workers were not happy with the decision, but the company said that it was because of the bad economy.
The pressure to agree: This is when people feel like they have to agree with the group or else they will be left out.
- Example: The group is talking about a new product and everyone seems to be agreeing with each other. But, you think that the product is not a good idea. You don’t say anything because you don’t want to be left out of the group.
Self-censorship: This is when people censor themselves because they don’t want to offend anyone in the group.
- Example: You have an idea for a new product, but you don’t say anything because you think that the group will not like your idea.
Unquestioned beliefs: This is when people believe what other people tell them without questioning it.
- Example: The group leader says that the new product is a great idea and everyone in the group agrees. But, you think that the product is not a good idea. You don’t say anything because you don’t want to question the group leader.
Mudguards: This is when someone in the group stops other people from questioning the group’s decisions.
- Example: The group leader says that the new product is a great idea and everyone in the group agrees. But, you think that the product is not a good idea. You don’t say anything because you don’t want to offend the group leader.
Causes of Groupthink
There are different causes of groupthink. Some of the most common causes are:
The need for consensus: This is when people want to agree with the group so badly that they will not question the group’s decisions.
The fear of disagreement: This is when people are afraid to disagree with the group.
Groupthink blindness: This is when people do not see that there is a problem with the group’s decision-making process.
Unquestioned beliefs: This is when people believe what other people tell them without questioning it.
The need to belong: This is when people want to be part of a group so badly that they will agree with the group even if they know the decision is wrong.
The fear of being wrong: This is when people are afraid to say anything that might be wrong. They would rather keep quiet and go along with the group than risk being wrong.
Risk Factors of Groupthink
There are different risk factors of groupthink. Some of the most common risk factors are:
Based on Composition
The leader of the group: The more autocratic the leader, the more likely it is for groupthink to happen.
The size of the group: The larger the group, the more likely it is for groupthink to happen.
The cohesiveness of the group: The more cohesive the group, the more likely it is for groupthink to happen.
The insulation of the group: The more insulated the group is from outside influences, the more likely it is for groupthink to happen.
Based on Belief
The culture of the group: The more conformist the culture, the more likely it is for groupthink to happen.
The belief in inherent morality: This is when the group thinks that its decisions are always right.
The illusion of unanimity: This is when the group thinks that everyone agrees with the group’s decisions.
The illusion of invulnerability: This is when the group thinks that it is immune to problems and mistakes.
History And Development
The term “groupthink” was first used by social psychologist Irving Janis in 1971. He noticed that groups often made bad decisions and he wanted to find out why. Janis studied the decision-making process of groups, and he came up with the theory of groupthink.
Recognizing Symptoms of Group Thinking
There are different symptoms of groupthink. Some of the most common symptoms are:
Fear of dissent: This is when the group does not want to disagree with the group.
Lack of critical thinking: This is when the group does not question the group’s decisions.
Manipulation of information: This is when the group hides information or distorts information so that it agrees with the group’s decisions.
Overestimating the group: This is when the group thinks that it is better and more powerful than it really is.
Underestimating the enemy: This is when the group thinks that the enemy is weaker and less powerful than it really is.
Quoting Examples of Group thinking
History is replete with examples of disastrous decisions made by groups that succumbed to groupthink. Some are as follows:
Society
The Salem witch trials are a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The Puritans were so afraid of Satan and witches that they started to believe that everyone was a witch. This led to the death of innocent people.
McCarthyism, 1950: Another example is McCarthyism in the 1950s. Senator Joseph McCarthy led a campaign to find communists in the government. This led to the persecution of innocent people.
Polity
The Iraq War is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The Bush administration was so sure that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction that they invaded Iraq without any evidence. This led to the death of innocent Iraqis and American soldiers.
The Vietnam War is another example of groupthink gone wrong. The Johnson administration was so sure that the North Vietnamese were going to take over South Vietnam that they sent American troops to fight in the war. This led to the death of innocent Vietnamese and American soldiers.
Business
Apple’s iPhone release, 2007: Apple’s decision to release the iPhone in 2007 is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The executives at Apple were so sure that the iPhone would be a success that they didn’t test it with consumers first. This led to the release of a product that was unpopular and had many glitches.
The Enron scandal is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The executives at Enron were so sure that they could get away with the accounting fraud that they continued to do it. This led to the bankruptcy of Enron and the largest corporate fraud in history.
Education
Common Core State Standards: The decision to adopt Common Core State Standards is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The education experts were so sure that the standards would improve student achievement that they didn’t bother to test them first. This led to the adoption of a set of standards that are unpopular and have not been shown to improve student achievement.
Standardized Test Scores: The decision to focus on standardized test scores is another example of groupthink gone wrong. The education experts were so sure that standardized test scores are the best way to measure student achievement that they didn’t bother to look at other measures. This led to the focus on standardized test scores in schools, which has had negative consequences for students.
Military
The Bay of Pigs Invasion is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The Kennedy administration was so sure that Fidel Castro was going to overthrow the Cuban government that they sent American troops to invade Cuba. This led to the death of innocent Cubans and American soldiers.
The Korean War is another example of groupthink gone wrong. The Truman administration was so sure that the North Korean army was going to invade South Korea that they sent American troops to fight in the war. This led to the death of innocent Koreans and American soldiers.
R&D
The Challenger disaster is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The NASA engineers were so sure that the Challenger shuttle was safe that they didn’t test it properly. This led to the explosion of the shuttle and the death of innocent astronauts.
The Ford Pinto is another example of groupthink gone wrong. The Ford engineers were so sure that the Pinto was safe that they didn’t test it properly. This led to the explosion of the car and the death of innocent drivers.
Health
The thalidomide scandal is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The executives at the company that made thalidomide were so sure that it was safe that they didn’t test it on pregnant women first. This led to the birth of babies with deformities.
Economy
The financial crisis of 2008 is a perfect example of groupthink gone wrong. The investment banks were so sure that housing prices would continue to go up that they invested in mortgage-backed securities. This led to the collapse of the housing market and the global financial crisis.
Analyzing Group thinking
Positives of Group thinking
Groupthink can have positive consequences for society. Some of the most common consequences are, the group:
- Makes good decisions: This is when the group decides to do something that is in the best interests of society.
- Considers all information: This is when the group listens to people who have different opinions.
- Creates an us-and-us mentality: This is when the group includes everyone and brings them together.
- Encourages creativity: This is when the group allows people to express their ideas freely.
Negatives of Group thinking
Groupthink can have negative consequences for society. Some of the most common consequences are, the group:
- Makes bad decisions: This is when the group decides to do something that is not in the best interests of society.
- Ignores critical information: This is when the group does not listen to people who have different opinions.
- Creates an us-versus-them mentality: This is when the group divides people into two groups and pits them against each other.
- Stifles creativity: This is when the group does not allow people to express their ideas freely.
Breaking Group thinking
To avoid groupthink, society can do the following:
- Encourage dissent: This is when people are allowed to express their opinions freely.
- Value-free speech: This is when people are allowed to say what they think without fear of retribution.
- Promote diversity: This is when people from different backgrounds and cultures come together.
- Encourage critical thinking: This is when people are allowed to think for themselves.
- Hear from experts: This is when people are allowed to hear from experts who have different opinions.
- Watch movies and read books: This is when people are allowed to watch movies and read books that deal with different points of view.
Dissent, free speech, diversity, critical thinking is important in avoiding groupthink because it allows for different opinions to be heard. When dissent is encouraged, people are more likely to express their opinions freely. This helps to prevent the formation of false consensus.
Hearing From Sociologists
When it comes to groupthink, it is important to hear from sociologists. They can provide valuable insight into the formation of false consensus and how to prevent it.
Sociologists have a lot to say about groupthink. Some of the things they say are, groupthink is:
- A major problem in society: This is because groupthink can lead to bad decisions.
- Result of conformist pressure: This is when people are pressured to agree with the group.
- Groupthink can be prevented: This is done by encouraging dissent, free speech, diversity, and critical thinking.
Movies And Books
Movies and books can also help to prevent groupthink. This is because they can provide different perspectives on an issue. When watching movies and reading books, people can see how groupthink can lead to negative consequences.
Some of the best movies and books to watch and read are:
- The Killing Fields: This is a movie about the Cambodian genocide. It shows how a group of people were able to convince themselves that killing innocent people was the right thing to do.
- The Crucible: This is a play about the Salem witch trials. It shows how groupthink can cause people to do terrible things.
- The Grapes of Wrath: This is a book about the Great Depression. It shows how groupthink can cause people to make bad decisions.
Conclusion
Groupthink is a major problem in society. It can lead to bad decisions and conformity pressure. However, by encouraging dissent, free speech, diversity, and critical thinking, society can mitigate the formation of false consensus. In addition, by hearing from experts, watching movies, and reading books, society can gain a better understanding of different points of view. This will help to prevent groupthink from occurring.
A Word From Therapy Mantra
Your mental health — Your psychological, emotional, and social well-being — has an impact on every aspect of your life. Positive mental health essentially allows you to effectively deal with life’s everyday challenges.
At TherapyMantra, we have a team of therapists who provide affordable online therapy to assist you with issues such as depression, anxiety, stress, workplace Issues, addiction, relationship, OCD, LGBTQ, and PTSD. You can book a free therapy or download our free Android or iOS app.
